| Individual Marks | # | Name | Season | College/University |
| Hit Streak | 21 | Chase Bruno | 2022 | Montreat College |
| Batting Average | .456 | Houston Wright | 2020 | University of Tennessee – Martin |
| On-Base Average | .545 | Alan Alonso | 2020 | University of Mount Olive |
| Slugging Average | .872 | Alan Alonso | 2020 | University of Mount Olive |
| OPS | 1.417 | Alan Alonso | 2020 | University of Mount Olive |
| Runs | 58 | Billy Wilson | 2017 | Loyola Marymount University |
| Hits | 81 | Joey Wendle | 2011 | West Chester University |
| Doubles | 22 | Adam Kirsch | 2013 | Texas Tech University |
| Triples | 5 | Brian Billigen | 2010 | Cornell University |
| Home Runs | 16 | Chad Sedio | 2015 | Miami University |
| RBI | 51 | Houston Wright | 2020 | University of Tennessee – Martin |
| Total Bases | 143 | Chad Sedio | 2015 | Miami University |
| Bases on Balls | 47 | Jake Placzek | 2014 | University of Nebraska |
| Hit by Pitch (Tied) | 11 | Peter Barrows | 2010 | University of Bridgeport |
| | 11 | Kevin Whitehead | 2011 | Texas Tech University |
| Stolen Bases | 35 | Ryan Brenner | 2011 | Miami University |
| Stolen Bases w/o Being Caught | 30 | Anthony Masselli | 2017 | Boston College |
| Sacrifice Hits | 19 | A.J. Rusbarsky | 2010 | Seton Hall University |
| Sacrifice Flies | 6 | Chance Shepard | 2015 | North Carolina State University |
| Starter ERA | 1.02 | Nick Miller | 2013 | University of Northern Colorado |
| Starter WHIP | 0.74 | Zach Prendergast | 2015 | Seton Hall University |
| Reliever ERA (Tied) | 0.47 | Kenny Elkind | 2007 | La Salle University |
| | 0.47 | Jeremy Bales | 2013 | Lee University |
| Reliever WHIP | 0.51 | Coty Saranthus | 2010 | Delta State University |
| Wins (Tied) | 7 | Coleman McKellar | 2005 | Chattanooga State Technical Community College |
| | 7 | Zach Groh | 2007 | Binghamton University |
| | 7 | Anthony Markham | 2009 | Charleston Southern University |
| | 7 | Coty Saranthus | 2010 | Delta State University |
| | 7 | Jake McCoy | 2013 | College of the Desert |
| Games | 36 | Dustin Quattrocchi | 2011 | Southern Illinois University-Edwardsville |
| Games Started | 12 | Whitley Benson | 2001 | University of North Carolina |
| Innings Pitched | 84 | Whitley Benson | 2001 | University of North Carolina |
| Complete Games | 6 | Chad Baumann | 1998 | Virginia Commonwealth University |
| Shutouts | 1 | Many Players | | |
| Saves (Tied) | 15 | Luke Demko | 2008 | University of Rhode Island |
| | 15 | Jordan Egan | 2012 | Norfolk State University |
| Strikeouts | 85 | Chris Spigner | 1999 | University of South Carolina |
| Strikeouts in a Game | 18 | Alex Shirazi | 2020 | Lenoir Rhyne University |
| Starter K/9 IP rate | 14.19 | Josiah Sightler | 2020 | University of South Carolina |
| Reliever K/9 IP rate | 21.09 | Ray Stocum | 2020 | Lenoir Rhyne University |
| Starter Walk rate/9 IP | .53 | Keith Couch | 2009 | Adelphi University |
| Reliever Walk rate/9 IP | 1.25 | Edgar Ramírez | 2004 | Louisiana State University |
| Starter K:BB rate | 17.00(51:3) | Danny Powers | 2004 | University of Central Missouri |
| Reliever K:BB rate | 10.00(30:3) | Edgar Ramírez | 2004 | Louisiana State University |
| Starter BAA | .148 | Chris Spigner | 1999 | University of South Carolina |
| Reliever BAA | .107 | Coty Saranthus | 2010 | Delta State University |
| Catcher Caught Stealing % | 39% | Dennis Blackmon | 2004 | Barton College |
| Catcher Fielding Average | 1.000 | Jason Agresti | 2017 | Binghamton University |
| First Base Fielding Average | 1.000 | Nick Miller | 2013 | University of Northern Colorado |
| Second Base Fielding Average | .995 | Mario Chaoui | 2004 | Florida Memorial University |
| Shortstop Fielding Average | .974 | Jake Evans | 2019 | Binghamton University |
| Third Base Fielding Average | .960 | Pat Feeney | 2006 | Marist College |
| Second Base Assists | 158 | Joey Wendle | 2011 | West Chester University |
| Shortstop Assists | 180 | A.J. Rusbarksy | 2010 | Seton Hall University |
| Third Base Assists | 123 | Josh Hampton | 2013 | Wilmington University |
| Outfielder Assists | 11 | Madison Beaird | 2012 | Arkansas Tech University |
| Outfielder Putouts | 124 | Ryan Brenner | 2011 | Miami University |
ONSL 
